Welcome to ValveTime

The number one place on the internet for Valve game discussion, news, and a community full of the best Valve fans.

The possible future of Chicken Farms

Discussion in 'The Lounge' started by Krynn72, Feb 17, 2012.

  1. Krynn72

    Krynn72 The Freeman

    http://io9.com/5885510/holy-crap-its-the-matrix-for-chickens
    [​IMG]

    What say you?
  2. Vegeta897

    Vegeta897 The Freeman

    I fully support this.
  3. Would it work in practice and be cost effective? Could be a good way to meet poultry demand. Free range chickens would get a boost too by the amount of people icked out by it (still a small percentage of poultry users, but enough to sustain free range as its own industry even more than it is now)
  4. Bad^Hat

    Bad^Hat The Freeman

    This makes me severely uncomfortable, not least because of the attitude that this kind of sentiment engenders:

    Does anyone else find the second sentence just as unsettling as the first? It's not just that he's saying we should completely depersonalize an animal, not only once it's dead meat but while it's still ostensibly "alive" (that's a whole other can of worms that I don't want to open), but also that animals don't even matter in the first place unless they're a) owned by a person, or b) being watched for the enjoyment of a person. Just... ugh.

    I don't know. All I can really say is that I'm not okay with it, but I can't really find a way to put that into an actual moral argument as yet that doesn't break down into airy fairy shit like "we should respect the animals' right to life, man."
  5. Vegeta897

    Vegeta897 The Freeman

    I don't think he was implying that with the David Attenborough thing. I think he just meant animals in the wild.

    Like there's 3 groups:
    Wild Animals
    Domesticated Animals
    Livestock
  6. Bad^Hat

    Bad^Hat The Freeman

    "Animals are things we keep in our homes and watch on David Attenborough programs."

    If he didn't mean to imply that, then his wording there is pretty ****ing unfortunate. Why would he chose to say it that way instead of stating that there are animals in the wild? Did he not think people would understand the concept without referring to TV?
  7. Krynn72

    Krynn72 The Freeman

    I'm pretty sure he just said that as a "witty" way of saying "Wild Animals" and the joke just fell flat. Probably because it was a shitty joke.
  8. DEATHMASTER

    DEATHMASTER The Freeman

    Wasn't there some genetically "grown" meat shown before? I think it was for some 'beef substitute.'
  9. Remus

    Remus Companion Cube

    It didn't help that I was listening to this while reading the article: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KgHylFxMef0

    Anyways, no I don't support this but I do support cloned meat. With cloned meat you completely sidestep the moral/ethical problems of harming other animals for food.

    The problem is that as far as I know things aren't exacly going too smoothly in the cloned meat department. Not to mention that the only person that has ever tasted the stuff (a crazy russian jurnalist) said it was hard and tasteless.
  10. Krynn72

    Krynn72 The Freeman

    Yep, and I support that without hesitation. This one is a little hazier, what with the whole lobotomizing fully functional living creatures for the purpose of growing them to eat. The notion that we should stop thinking of them as living creatures and as crops is far more unsettling, and harder to sell to me than test-tube grown meat that never had a nervous system/brain to begin with.

    But this does sound better to me than the current state of affairs, and I guess thats what really counts? Would I rather have matrix chickens, or stuck with how its done today? I gotta say Matrix chickens.
  11. ZT

    ZT The Freeman

    Agreed, that was really uncomfortable to read, and quite frankly detached and sociopathic.
  12. Krynn72

    Krynn72 The Freeman

    [​IMG]
  13. ZT

    ZT The Freeman

    Why don't you just go ahead and buy some Psychopathic Records, you psychopath.
  14. Dinnesch

    Dinnesch Space Core

    One of the good solutions to factory farming, but I don't think it's going to be possible anytime soon.

    The other is just banning it, our economies also didn't collapse when it became illegal to use black people as slaves(sorry if this comparison sounds offensive but you get the point).
  15. BabyHeadCrab

    BabyHeadCrab The Freeman

    Our economy did collapse, though. The South became a ruin until technology and flight towards urban development from governmental assistance took hold.
  16. Maestro

    Maestro The Freeman

    It also started a war. Banning factory farming is a terrible solution to the problem. That will only create a black market with nonexistent regulation.
  17. KiplingsCat

    KiplingsCat Space Core

    I don't know. Seems kind of Soylent Green-ish.

    SOYLENT GREEN IS PEOPLE!!!
  18. Stigmata

    Stigmata The Freeman

    Yeah this makes me really uncomfortable for all the reasons stated by BadHat and ZT and Krynn. I guess 'Murica needs its KFC for national security purposes or something.

    Soylent Green tastes like chicken
  19. mechanicallizard

    mechanicallizard Party Escort Bot

    This is ****ed up, and I think part of the reason I find it so uncomfortable is that I can see this becoming the norm, whether its tomorrow or in 20 years.
  20. dfc05

    dfc05 Tank

    This. I mean, if the animal is going to live horribly and die anyways, maybe it's not that much worse to lobotomize it first. At this point though, it still seems weird. Maybe the chickens would rather have social functions than a painless "life", I dunno. I tend to avoid these issues because I'm not a vegetarian and don't buy free-range meat even though I know it's bad. But I have been eating less meat now.

    I do think raising chickens this way would turn off more people from meat, just because they have ethical hang-ups on the "purity" of their food (see GMO crops -- not actually hazardous but public opinion has screwed that industry over). So I doubt it will actually be done.
  21. You guys are ridiculous. I'd rather eat chicken from this system than ones today where chickens are crammed together and stressed the hell out. Stress releases stress hormones over their entire life and effects their growth and taste. Nasty. I'd rather have either the matrix chickens or free range chickens than current factory farm chickens.
  22. Dandan

    Dandan Medic

    I for one am becoming a vegetarian....once a month. I think I can handle it
  23. Krynn72

    Krynn72 The Freeman

    Thats my stance as well. We all would like the perfect solution, but really the question here is; would you rather have today's factory farms, or this new matrix system?
  24. Vegeta897

    Vegeta897 The Freeman

    For some reason this concept feels like it fits in perfectly with my idea of a futuristic world like in Blade Runner, so I like it.
  25. Remus

    Remus Companion Cube

    Neither. Cloned meat, damn it.
  26. Stylo

    Stylo The Freeman

    PETA are going to go f*cking nuts.
  27. BabyHeadCrab

    BabyHeadCrab The Freeman

    I'm sure there's a fiery place in hell for folks like me, but I genuinely don't care about the suffering endured by the animals I consume. Even if they are smarter than my housecats or dog. I'm sure they wouldn't taste nearly as good.
  28. I would think the fiery place in hell would be for people that make animals suffer. The matrix system's whole point is no suffering.
  29. ZT

    ZT The Freeman

    In Blade Runner the majority of animals are extinct due to the war's radiation and now only android animals remain unless you are incredibly rich. So this would not fit into the Blade Runner Universe, noob.
  30. Maestro

    Maestro The Freeman

    Is that mentioned in Blade Runner? I thought that was just in Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? It's been forever since I've seen the movie/read the book.

    I should go re-read those...
  31. mechanicallizard

    mechanicallizard Party Escort Bot

    So, just out of curiosity, what do they eat?
  32. ZT

    ZT The Freeman



    Chinese noodles apparently!
  33. Remus

    Remus Companion Cube

    They are all really androids, they just don't know it!

    *head explodes*
  34. mechanicallizard

    mechanicallizard Party Escort Bot

    I see....
  35. Bad^Hat

    Bad^Hat The Freeman

    Phew, good thing they have no souls.
  36. Vegeta897

    Vegeta897 The Freeman

    Yeah those animals aren't used for eating, which is part of the point of the thread. This is like growing meat in a field. I wouldn't consider them animals, more like plants with a heartbeat.
  37. Bad^Hat

    Bad^Hat The Freeman

    I am still genuinely conflicted about this. My egalitarianism is clashing with my materialism/nihilism. :v
  38. 15357

    15357 Companion Cube

    Well, I think this is a way better idea than the current farms. I mean, put yourself in the chicken's position: would you rather spend your whole life inside a crammed cage or rather not live at all?
  39. Mr Stabby

    Mr Stabby Tank

    I think I just became a vegetarian.
  40. Tagaziel

    Tagaziel Party Escort Bot

    Welcome to the club.

    On the subject of food in Blade Runner: unless my BR-sense fails me, it's typically artifically grown meat, soya and other easy to mass produce things.

Share This Page